Guide for ICF Mentor Coaches

How to Guide Aspiring Coaches: An ICF Mentor Coaching Guide

The International Coach Federation (ICF) credentialing process plays a vital role in ensuring the quality and effectiveness of professional coaches. Within this framework, ICF Mentor Coaches act as crucial guides for aspiring coaches, helping them refine their skills and demonstrate mastery of the ICF Core Competencies. This mentor coaching guide explores the key responsibilities of an ICF Mentor Coach, drawing on the provided information and relevant sources.

Active Listening: The Bedrock of Effective Feedback

At the heart of successful mentor coaching lies the ability to listen actively. An ICF Mentor Coach goes beyond simply comprehending the content of a mentee’s coaching session. They actively listen “beyond content” to discern how the mentee is applying the ICF Core Competencies in their interactions with the client. This involves differentiating between skill versus direction, skill versus style, and skill versus outcome for the client. For example, a mentor coach might observe a mentee using powerful open-ended questions (a skill), but not necessarily guiding them towards the client’s stated goals (direction).

Active listening also encompasses understanding the client and mentee on multiple levels: physical, intellectual, emotional, and intuitive. This heightened awareness allows the mentor coach to pick up on subtle cues that might otherwise be missed, leading to richer feedback tailored to the specific needs of the mentee.

Building a Safe Growth Space for the Mentee

The ICF Code of Ethics emphasizes the importance of creating a safe and supportive environment for coaching clients. This principle extends to the mentor coaching relationship as well. An ICF Mentor Coach fosters a safe and trusting space by employing a respectful, clear, and judgment-free tone. This allows the mentee to feel comfortable asking questions, exploring areas of uncertainty, and receiving feedback without fear of criticism.

Providing Targeted and Competency-Based Feedback

Effective feedback is a cornerstone of mentor coaching. An ICF Mentor Coach possesses a working knowledge of the assessment tools used by the ICF to evaluate coaching sessions during the credentialing process. This knowledge allows them to assess the mentee’s application of the ICF Core Competencies within the context of their coaching practice.

Beyond simply identifying the presence or absence of individual competencies, ICF Mentor Coaches excel at pinpointing the critical underlying competencies that might be hindering the mentee’s coaching impact. They can discern and articulate the gap between the mentee’s current skill level and the next level they need to attain. Crucially, they achieve this by using competency-based language and specific behavioral examples drawn directly from the mentee’s coaching sessions.

Delivering Feedback with Sensitivity and Respect

While providing constructive feedback is essential, the manner of delivery plays a critical role. ICF Mentor Coaches are skilled at delivering feedback with sensitivity to the impact it might have on the mentee. They present their observations with specific details and examples, by ensuring clarity and actionable next steps.

Furthermore, ICF Mentor Coaches understand the importance of recognizing strengths as well as areas for growth. They offer feedback that is relevant to each specific coaching core competency, highlighting the mentee’s existing strengths and pinpointing areas where additional development would be beneficial. The mentor coach guides the mentee toward advancing their coaching skills.

Maintaining Objectivity and Focus on Skills

Coaching can be a highly personal practice, and different coaches develop their own unique styles. However, during mentor coaching, it is crucial to maintain objectivity. An ICF Mentor Coach demonstrates the ability to self-manage relative to their own coaching model preferences. They remain focused on the core competencies and their assessment, ensuring that their feedback centers on skill development rather than promoting a specific coaching style.


ICF Mentor Coaches play a vital role in supporting aspiring coaches on their journey towards ICF credentialing. Keeping in mind these core concepts in this mentor coaching guide will allow you to help your mentee through active listening, targeted feedback, and a commitment to creating a safe and supportive environment, As an ICF Mentor Coach, you will empower mentees to refine their skills, master the ICF Core Competencies, and ultimately become effective and ethical coaches.


International Coach Federation:
Mentor Coaching Duties and Competencies:
A Guide To ICF Mentor Coaching for Achieving Your ICF Certification:

Hope Bundrant
Visit Us
Scroll to Top